Home Gaming 7 Best PS5 Horror Games for Every Type of Horror Fan

7 Best PS5 Horror Games for Every Type of Horror Fan

by Isabella Dager
PS5 Horror Games

Horror games are a popular genre among PS5 players who enjoy the thrill of being scared and challenged. However, not all horror games are created equal. Some are more difficult than others, requiring skill, strategy, and perseverance to overcome the obstacles and enemies. In this article, we rank the 7 toughest PS5 horror games based on their completion percentage, which indicates how many players have achieved the final trophy or achievement in the game. The lower the percentage, the harder the game.

Best PS5 Horror Games

PS5 horror games are the perfect choice for gamers who love to be scared and challenged. From psychological horror to zombie action, there is a game for every type of horror fan. Here are some of the best PS5 horror games that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

1. Alan Wake 2

Alan Wake 2

Completion Percentage: 12.5% (The Story Come True Trophy)

Alan Wake 2 is a survival horror game that continues the story of Alan Wake, a bestselling author who fights against the dark forces that haunt his mind and reality. The game is set in Bright Falls, a small town in Washington, where Alan has to face new threats and mysteries. The game features a dynamic day-night cycle, a flashlight mechanic, and a combat system that requires players to use light and weapons to fend off the enemies. Alan Wake 2 is a difficult game, as players have to conserve their resources, avoid the darkness, and survive the unpredictable events that happen in the game.

2. Returnal


Completion Percentage: 5.9% (White Shadow Trophy)

Returnal is a horror roguelike game that puts players in the shoes of Selene, an astronaut who crash-lands on a hostile alien planet and gets trapped in a time loop. Every time she dies, she wakes up at the same point, but the world changes around her. The game features fast-paced combat, procedurally generated environments, and psychological horror elements. Returnal is extremely hard, as players have to start from scratch every time they die, losing all their progress and items. The game also has no difficulty settings, meaning players have to face the same level of challenge throughout. Only a few players have managed to break the cycle and reach the true ending of the game.

3. Lies of P

Lies of P

Completion Percentage: 21.6% (Rise of P Trophy)

Lies of P is a horror action RPG that reimagines the classic story of Pinocchio in a dark and twisted way. Players take on the role of P, a wooden puppet who wakes up in a plague-ridden city and seeks to become a real human. The game is inspired by the Souls series, featuring challenging combat, exploration, and customization. Players have to face various enemies, bosses, and traps, as well as make choices that affect the story and the character’s appearance. Lies of P is a hard game, as players have to manage their stamina, health, and weapons, as well as deal with the consequences of their lies.

4. Dead Island 2

Dead Island 2

Completion Percentage: 41.2% (Our True Nature Trophy)

Dead Island 2 is a horror action game that takes place in a zombie-infested California. Players can choose from four different characters, each with their own skills and abilities, and team up with other players online to fight against the undead hordes. The game features a large open world, a crafting system, and a variety of weapons and vehicles. Dead Island 2 is a challenging game, as players have to scavenge for supplies, deal with different types of zombies, and face human enemies and bosses. The game also has a scaling difficulty, meaning the zombies become stronger and more aggressive as the game progresses.

5. Resident Evil 2

Resident Evil 2

Completion Percentage: 50.4% (A Hero Emerges Trophy)

Resident Evil 2 is a horror survival game that is a remake of the 1998 game of the same name. The game follows Leon Kennedy and Claire Redfield, two survivors who have to escape from Raccoon City, a city that has been overrun by zombies and other creatures. The game features stunning graphics, realistic physics, and a revamped gameplay that combines action and puzzle-solving. Resident Evil 2 is a tough game, as players have to manage their inventory, ammo, and health, as well as avoid or fight against the enemies, including the relentless Tyrant. The game also has multiple scenarios, modes, and difficulties, offering a high replay value and challenge.

6. Resident Evil 4

Resident Evil 4

Completion Percentage: 61.6% (You’re Small Time! Trophy)

Resident Evil 4 is a horror action game that is a remake of the 2005 game of the same name. The game follows Leon Kennedy, a special agent who is sent to rescue the president’s daughter from a cult in Spain. The game features a third-person perspective, a new aiming system, and a variety of weapons and items. Resident Evil 4 is a difficult game, as players have to face hordes of enemies, including villagers, soldiers, and mutants, as well as solve puzzles, escort the daughter, and survive the boss battles. The game also has scarce ammo and health, as well as tricky map navigation, making it a scary and demanding experience.

7. Dead Space

Dead Space

Completion Percentage: 41.8% (Exodus Trophy)

Dead Space is a horror sci-fi game that follows Isaac Clarke, an engineer who is sent to repair a spaceship that has been attacked by a mysterious alien infection. The game is a remake of the original 2008 game, featuring improved graphics, gameplay, and sound. The game is known for its atmospheric and claustrophobic setting, as well as its gruesome and terrifying enemies, called Necromorphs. Dead Space is a hard game, as players have to use strategic dismemberment to kill the Necromorphs, as well as solve puzzles, hack terminals, and navigate zero-gravity environments. The game also has limited ammo and health, adding to the tension and difficulty.

If you are interested in knowing more details about Horror Movies to Watch on Hulu, then read Top 10 Horror Movies to Watch on Hulu Right Now.


PS5 is a great platform for horror fans, as it offers a wide range of games that cater to different tastes and preferences. Whether you want to experience the fear of being hunted, the thrill of fighting back, or the mystery of unraveling the truth, there is a PS5 Horror Games for you. From the classics like Resident Evil 2 and 4, to the new and innovative titles like Returnal and Lies of P, these games will keep you on the edge of your seat and make your heart race. If you are looking for some of the best horror games on PS5, you can’t go wrong with these 7 choices.

You may also like

Leave a Comment

* By using this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by this website.